Aolyl eia ab huseyb sk ftq Iyvdupun rudqp. Gur uhfrlo qum hizvyilk pm lzw ybqxw vtkrqf ibbikpml zu hvs cxy zq iwt Zyezd. P’k duluh zclyx egot b pxtihg. Bg cajrwrwp Y’t vyhut f ixehj fyvwx ct ob S-60 cvu rc pil illu h mnonnylcha pkxqe xqixkbxgvx wzivu vwdqglqj mr dro tkkmfsi yxbrcrxw. V jfxji utvd sr kyv mkbzzxk, dv cqn ljsuwjk vcn ydje xli fbw-itkm qh ymj kvohmf twppkpi juxwp nby hgyk pg esp bcff. Ftq vjc ptl gacchv, wkh tmeadhxdch xfwetawjtyr lgfe sri obchvsf lxus gur lkbbov, uwzm yunjbrwp cqjw psyh.
Rad zvtl viewsr Y pil hin gzrgevgf kyv zapcletyr ngtjrk yt mimvo ihjr qcnb iegl ixej, iba wh lql. Zvtlovd yj xbt na xmm rkj uvtcpigna zmiaaczqvo mylcym pg acjsasbhg. S vyyuon lwev aflg aol frrt cpy cqn vqrhys dgnv fjb rqqpuzs liohxm zu uaz du. N bmgeqp wfi u gfx gsqcbrg, ldcstgxcv mj Kvshfot, Mbzuly mzp bpm wbpmza oria nwxdpq je wkuo nbycl iylhr ibrsf kyv seluh bs wi uxgt. N bfnyji s kjb vhfrqgv svwfiv varrotm vu bpm mjuumf jhywwuh iwpi hijrz rxw bs ymj tsuc iz znk aoh’m tgegkxgt. Y bvxxcquh iwkfgf hvs rotk bs qwddgo kirtvi dayzlk hc hvs tjef fw dro bcff, pvpx…
Thanks for reading this short excerpt from the paid post! Fancy buying it to read all of it?
Jim! been a bit since I wrote but I have to catch my breath being a citizen of many named valleys of RVN. One thing that caught my eye and I did not know, was the gifting of the Ontos to the Army when the Marines were pulling out. My dear friend Bruce Morton commanded them in their glory days in Hue in 68, good Lord they saved a lot of us. I must say this is the most riveting collection of combat recollections that I have ever read. To those of us who humped the A shau and so many other hills and valleys looking for Sir Charles this is the story of ouryouth. See you soon Semper Fi
I much appreciate those words Capt. Yes, that valley was something, indeed.
Maybe I should have used the name in the title but I decided to be more general about the experience
rather than the place. The place could be anywhere in combat, the rules, or the lack of them, are the same.
It’s simply in the renditions and telling of them that mythology and fable are generally
sought out as places to hide what really goes on.
Until Vietnam I thought Goldman’s about those children on that island (Lord of the Flies)
was a flight of the purest fantasy.
Only in Vietnam did I figure out the only fable part of it was the Navy Officer showing up in the end
to save the kids that were left. Thanks for the comment and your support.
Semper fi,
Jim
James I have a short story for you that I think you will like. It is about what happened when I went to put flags on veterans graves at the cemetery last Monday. But I would like to put it in an email. But I don’t know your email address. Can you send it to me?
My email is antaresproductions@charter.net and my phone is 2625815300. Thanks for whatever you send.
I will read and get back to you. That’s a nice and trusting thing to do and I thank you.
Semper fi,
Jim
I think I’d like to buy the whole book, or books at one time. I would even order in advance. S/F JP
I am writing the segments that make up the novels as fast as I can. The next book should be out
in August and then the third in December. The first is on Amazon and Barnes and Noble. I have no ‘real’ publisher so I am banned from
being on book shelves or in regular book stores or even grocery stores or airports. Just the way it is.
Thanks for wanting the books.
Semper fi,
Jim
I read the first book, and now I’m afraid to read these segments, for fear of ruining the book. When can we expect the next book, the second 10 days?
August 1 is the target date, Roy. And thank you for that compliment…
Semper fi
Jim
Will you finish the last five days online?
I am on the 15th night. I will finish the reaming days of both books online, unless some big
publisher swoops in and won’t let me. I doubt that, so I intend to keep on going just like I have been.
Besides, what would I do without my traveling salvation army of commenters here. Better than Facebook friends!
Semper fi,
Jim
With you on thoughts of a movie being made Lt. Rule number 1 in this land of silly asses we share is “If it thinks it stinks”.
I truly doubt anyone who hasn’t partaken of the commingled aroma of piss, shit and charcoal can ever understand that peninsula. For those who partook this book is a definitive text. Mr Charles and I long ago made peace, he was doing his thing I was doing mine, and it came out as it came out. My problems are not with Mr Charles, they are with US politicians and citizens. I could and did respect Mr Charles, I have no respect for the scum I came back to. They doubtless shared that feeling.
My email from 40 year old men I’ve introduced your book to currently runs 3.7 emails a day asking “Is this shit really true?”.
For those who understand, no explanation is needed.
For those who don’t, none is possible.
My mind and my memories wander as I read your words. We are today what and where we are. We gave no quarter and we owe nothing. Scanning the tree line is perfectly normal while riding the lawn mower.
Thanks a ton SCPO. You are so right about that tree line thing….and fields of fire, of course.
Semper fi, my friend,
Jim
Well said. People in general don’t understand the military and political leaders have screwed with it trying to change the mission to one of PC.
The military was and remains out there. Placed by people who have never and will never fight.
Even future leadership remains woefully ignorant of actual combat and conflict. The nation will
not elect real veterans because the regular population does not want to know.
There it is…did Bob Dole win? McCain? Kerry? Not a chance. They were not beaten by men
who simply hadn’t served. They were beaten by men who’d avoided service or combat. And the public was well
aware of that fact.
Semper fi,
Jim
Dole was a leader of the good ole boys, McCain and Kerry traitors and idiots in that order. Thank God none of them ever became president of this country.
Evening Jim, 48 years and some, The things that are still ready to bleed again, I am hoping against hope, That Jurgens is the screw up that He really is and missed Nguyen, Jurgens is the kind of bully that needs underlings to do his dirty work, You know the type, they never really have the gut to carry out the really dirty work, They are mean and nasty, but never seem to want the blood in their hands, and when they do try and do the deed, They really don’t have the skills…… May be 48 years to late, But I am praying against the odds for Nguyen, and hope that Murphy decided to stick his finger in Jurgen eye when He pulled the trigger. If not, You need to make that walk, Jurgens is to stupid to be left running around loose, Didn’t he have the brains to see how critical Nguyen was to keep Him alive, along with the rest of the company? But them venial leaches like Jurgans never had a long view in the game, Yep, 2 to the nuts one between the eyes, and feed the carcass to the gators…… The Humong dod not give their loyalty lightly, But when they did, Nguyen would have kept that word to the end.
My prayers for the Man, Even 48 years late, May God Watch Over Him.
Semper fi/This We Defend Bob.
Thanks Robert, your intensity is wonderful and you care even more appreciated.
It was a tough expensive time when it came to Marines over there.
Semper fi,
Jim
If one really wants to be truthful, there was no need for marines or any of our other troops, to be in Vietnam to begin with and therein lies a multitude of sins that our troops have been forced to bare.
The Military Industrial Complex was, at that time, in search of a small theater wherein they could
test all these new-fangled weapons that were being invented and also get rid of old equipment and inventory
so they could replace it with new stuff.
I now have come to believe that that was the truth about the war there,
that and letting the communist nations know that the U.S. was not a paper tiger.
And everyone was sent by people who did not have to, did not want to go
and everyone in combat was sent out there from those in the rear who did not have to
or want to go out there to the field. You ended up dead, badly wounded or
simply screwed up mentally if you pulled the short straw….
but you don’t get to know that until much later…
if you lived.
Thanks for the comment, as usual.
Semper fi,
Jim
Yes, it is a shame that our people and legislators, did not heed the warning of Gen. Eisenhower about the military complex.
We never seem to learn though, look at us now over in the M.E. and Afghanistan. Every one of those wars have been fought over time immemorial and nothing was ever resolved except the deaths they perpetuated. I guess that is the way mankind handles population control.
Stuff. It’s all about stuff. Genetic stuff.
We are driven as human beings to maximize our own survival and comfort
to propagate and then favor the progeny that result from that propagation.
Deception is our main tool in dealing with the universe and our fellow humans.
Hence, war after war after war….
Life is not fair because we cannot genetically
allow it to be fair, while we lie about that simple obvious fact.
Thanks for writing such cogent stuff, as usual, my friend.
Semper fi,
Jim
I have struggled with the thought of contacting you. It may be moot… maybe not. There is a Nam Vet who wanted his project secret so no one would disrespect it. So, I have volleyed the pros and cons of announcing it to others, to you. Yet his project is to honor all our Vietnam Veterans and he wanted to publically illustrate that respect somehow… so maybe he really wanted people to find out in the end. I do not know. Thus my quandary. The battle from within… silence fuels all lies. Thanks for Your honesty.
This is not a lie but was to originally remain silent by the author…maybe. There is a secret shrine hidden near the Continental Divide, in the mountains of Colorado, dedicated to all Vietnam Veterans… all Vietnam Veterans. It was intended to be kept secret (by the author) but recently someone accidentally found it and now it’s existence is slipping out to the public. Maybe you already know of it, maybe you think I should keep my mouth shut. That quandary again. I respect your decision on how you will address this issue, you have earned the right.
Healing too battles with silence, so I feel compelled to lance the wound and allow the possibility for recovery. The Vietnam Vets deserve the risk.
The shrine dedicated to all Vietnam Vets is called “Soldierstone”. You can find it on the web now, just Google it. It is a blessing to me and brings comfort. I work at a VA Clinic and have disclosed the secret to some Vietnam Vets, hopefully bringing them some comfort. I do not tell all vets only the ones who displace the remnant energies of Vietnam. I apologize if I have failed the Lt. Colonial’s wishes… the possibility of healing always trumps silence. I hope you are not displeased with my post. The secret is now yours.
Well, interesting. I nave no idea why any monument to those lost and to that war wuuld
be secret from anyone. How do monuments honor anyone or anything? They can be a place where
similar minded vets can get together but I am not aware they do at such places.
Thank you for the confidence and for the name of the place. You are right, the location is on
Google for those choosing to look it up. Maybe the secret part will attract some guys and gals to the location.
Be interesting to find out…
Thank you most sincerely,
Semper fi,
Jim
http://hiddencolorado.kunc.org/soldierstone/
Thanks Clair. Appreciate the link…
Semper fi,
Jim
Black Pony Home Page
To Honor the Forgotten
• SOLDIERSTONE •
• In Memory Of Long Wars Lost And The Soldiers Of •
• VIETNAM • LAOS • CAMBODIA •
• Like The Fallen Leaves Of Autumn In Unregimented Ranks
Unremembered Soldiers Rest Eternally •
• “If By Weeping I Could Change The Course Of Events, My Tears
Would Pour Down Ceaselessly For A Thousand Autumns.” •
• The Appointed Time To Be Born To Die, To Love,
To Hate Of WAR For PEACE •
• Still In Death Lies Everyone, And The Battle’s Lost •
• SACRIFICE • COURAGE • VALOR • HONOR •
In an unpublished book meant to accompany SOLDIERSTONE called Leaves of Stone, He wrote that one purpose is to “serve as a poignant reminder of our battlefield allies. It also asks of America the maturity to honor the defiant stands of soldiers in their seasons of death.” Monuments rarely change, but the people and circumstances surrounding them do.
Rest in peace Lieutenant Colonel
thanks for putting that up here Stephen. I am sure a lot of the guys, like me, really care…and appreciate..
Semper fi,
Jim
I cannot be sure why the Lt. Col. located this Memorial in a secret spot however these are my thoughts.
Soldierstone is in a faraway forgotten, difficult place, just like Nam was.
Soldierstone is on the high ground of the Continental Divide, in Nam the high ground was usually the safer place to gather.
The general public probably would not put out the required effort to get there, Nam vets have the resolve to go most anywhere. Especially to honor their brothers.
Therefore, I believe the Lt. Col. planned Soldierstone to be a shrine dedicated to Vietnam Veterans exclusively so they could find peace, seclusion and healing. I believe Soldierstone is being used by Vietnam Vets because of the attractiveness of the solitude. Who needs the general public at this very personal shrine.
I encourage vets to view the video shot by the young lady who found Soldierstone. It depicts a beautiful and heartfelt dedication to all Vietnam Veterans including the Kit Carson’s, the Hmong and all of our allies. I also suggest everyone read about the Lt. Col. who designed and built Soldierstone (all at his own expense), then you may get a feel for his determination to honor all Vietnam Veterans.
I could not agree or support you more in the words you’ve laid down here. Thank’s so much Pop!
Semper fi,
Jim
Well I know that 15 days in a bad situation can feel like a life time !! With that being said you sure can get yourself in a world of shit in a short amount of time ! I’m so glad you decided to share your story. I feel it’s helpful to alot of ppl in some many different ways . Thank you Sir
It was quite a run and the activity level alone was astounding. From the moment that door opened until the choppers flew out.
All the way all the time…
Thank you for writing a comment here about your own thoughts.
Semper fi,
Jim
We destroyed our FSB in QueSon Valley SW of DaNang. Came north and worked as a reactionary force in May of 68 for the assault into A Shau Valley. Lots of encounters with regulars. As senior medic of an infantry I even lost a couple of my medics. I finish each chapter quivering, adrenaline ready for the next ambush or whatever. You have zeroed in on the raw emotion that those of us who lived it and feel it again as we read. Thank you for telling the story so eloquently that we were unable to tell to those who do not know or understand. God Bless, Doc
Yes, Roland. To tell the true story is to have some indicate that it cannot be true.
That such awful stuff would not have been supported or tolerated and, after all, the reports of combat are
so much different. The movies cannot all lie….even if they do.
Thanks for your support, brother,
Semper fi,
Jim
I’m not exactly sure where to start. I have – in my mind – written as many comments as there are chapters to date in this story. I tripped over the Ninth Day in a FB post (direct marketing I think they call it). I read forward to Day 14, then like others that have commented, I backtracked and started at Day 1. I thought “Holy crap, Batman” before someone else wrote it in the comments a few weeks ago. I have pushed the link to many friends, dad-veterans thereof, and bought two of the First Ten. I gave one to a Marine buddy with all appropriate endorsements.
First, Jim, you and yours are larger than life, then not, as you are humbled with the reality of your situation. Basically, in 2 weeks, you have experienced a level of adrenaline, relational intimacy, sadness and physical exertion that most men would not experience in a lifetime. And you were what, 23 at the time? I’m 53, so sort of that “tweener generation” whose grandparents shouldered the load during WWII and Korea, dads served in Vietnam (college kept my dad out), and now a younger generation fights “in the sandbox.”
But I am intrigued with the human dynamic of that sort of mess, having grown up in the romanticized world of honor, courage and valor without really knowing what it looks like when you’re ass deep in crocodiles. Literally. So I’ve read a lot of novels and some are good at explaining the human dimension; you are truly gifted in that regard. Your writing reminds me of The 13th Valley by John DelVecchio (I think; he was also there), only your first person “so I shot him in the ass” spares no margin for how things are going to go if you have the stick.
Like so many others, I check often for the next installment but I don’t want you to rush it – for your sake as much as mine. Good story telling takes time, even when it’s true story-no lie kind of stuff. I thoroughly enjoy the comments and your responses as you and your brothers/sisters wend your way through the electrified cobwebs of the attic trunk you never wanted to open again, buried in a forgotten corner of your collective brain. I, for one, am glad you chose to take that risk.
In this post-Memorial Day week, my heart is notched for you guys that endured for each other as much or more as for country and apple pie. To all the veterans on this page and the ones lurking in the background, thank you – a thousand thousand times.
Thanks Daddy. I don’t know what to say about such a well written heartfelt comment.
You are a class act and you are also very accurate. This all could have simply gone by the boards.
Not like I don’t have enough going on.
But starting and running my own little controversial newspaper helped
me get ready for the heat I knew I would take.
You cannot tell the truth about what we went through and not take heat.
Those that were close in the rear but not in the shit don’t much care for these revelations.
Many came home undamaged and wanting to be the combat veterans without any
comprehension that the combat veterans did not want to be that at all.
And then there’s all the rest who don’t have a clue.
thanks for your support and writ5ing like you do on here….
I can’t tell you how much I appreciate it…
Semper fi,
Jim
When you wrote about the rope, “It was a hemp braided rope, not made of polypropylene or any modern substance,” I wondered if you were comparing it to something that had not yet been invented. But a little online research showed me that polypropylene fibers were being produced in industrial quantities in the US and Europe in the late 1950s. Still, the comment seemed a little “out of time.”
I worked two summers in the merchant marines and on pusher tug boats
during college before the Nam. I was quite used to the poly lines
for the barges and for tying up the big ore boats.
Thanks for the conjecture and the comment…
Semper fi,
Jim
Have been following the Jergens saga, in my mind, but it is still hard for me to grasp how twisted the mind of a man can become whatever the circumstance. Egotism, conceit and extreme jealously must surely go hand in hand at times. Take care Lt. you have stepped on the tail of the snake.
Jurgens was not a snake. He was quicker than that. More like an unprincipled Mongoose.
Thanks for the analysis and the recognition of my portrayal of another complex character of the combat.
They were real men and real Marines, as flawed as they were lethal…all of us…
Semper fi,
Jim
Jurgens didn’t chunk the rope to the bank as instructed!! He conned a rookie into doing it & Tex didn’t know not to continue standing up !! I hope that Jurgens didn’t shoot him , but don’t look good & if so , why ?? Tag & bag him !! Keep on keeping on !!
It was a hand. The company was a hand where the dealer in the rear with the gear kept sending in new
cards. You had to play what was dealt and that meant good cards as well as bad. Thanks for the analysis
and your conclusion, and writing it on here.
Semper fi,
Jim
Love that response, you have to play the hand you are dealt. The story of life.
Yes, it is a truism of life that has remained with me through time. We are seldom in as much
control of the hands we must play on the table. We just think we are. And yet we must play them,
and later rationalize how we dealt the hand in the first place.
Thanks for the depth of your short comment.
Semper fi,
Jim
I as a retired Lieutenant of the NYC Police Department proudly wear a Marine Corps Field Cover with the USMC emblem. My Dad and my father in law both were former Marines who never would talk about their experiences in the Pacific Theatre.
Now I know why they would not speak. I proudly wear that tattered and frayed USMC cover and everywhere I go I run across gents who proudly hail me “Semper Fi”.
I do not feel ashamed as I served 20 years on the mean streets of NYC. I have stared down the barrel of a weapon aimed at me and I survived. Again and again.
And again and again former Marines stood alongside me and we also survived.
I only had probably 30 minutes out of 20 years where I was in a firefight. It rocked me then and it still haunts me. The taking of a human life is a terrible thing even though it was necessary, justified and required so I could go home to my family. I still have nightmares where my revolver would not fire or I was out of ammo and then I wake up before the end……It sucks! Here I sit in an airconditioned home in the nosebleed area of Sun City in Las Vegas over 30 years later and I still have those damned dreams….They do not stop…..
I wonder how you make it every day cuz you have to have nasty dreams also.
Well, Dan, you get older and the repetitive nature of dreams and aromas and songs and all of it
repeats so many times that it all becomes one kind of familiar symphony…either that or you don’t
survive it at all. I suppose. Thanks for the heartfelt comment and the expression of some deep thinking.
Hope you like the Las Vegas living…a little too fast for me, but I can sure understand.
Semper fi,
Jim
Nothing fast here in Viagra Falls. This is a seniors only residential community built on Howard Hughes land by Del Webb. Very quiet neighborhood. Average age in the 70’s and somewhat active. I have and ride a ’07 Triumph Speedmaster motorcycle and I have two neighbors no more than 500 feet away also with bikes. They are always inviting me on their rides. Great fun and decent people. I am an active target shooter and I regularly participate in matches at a local outdoor range utilizing my pair of M 1’s, Winchester 94 30-30, Marlin 38-55 Winchester, Winchester Model 1885 50-90 Sharps and a half dozen handguns in steel and sillouette style contests. No big prizes but a lot of fun.
I also cast my own bullets from alloy I smelt and reload all my 25 firearms except for the .22’s and shotguns. I have active all around me and I always am packing as I have a CCW and I feel naked without a decent autoloader or a revolver on my person. I hardly every go into a casino as I do not gamble at all. You can be a hermit or be active as there is an activity for everybody if you want to make the effort.
Life is good here except from now til October as it gets and stays hot here for about 4 and half months. WE have had snow on the ground here exactly 3 times in the past 22 years and it was gone the next day.
Glad you found a place that makes you happy. The riding and shooting sound like
a lot of fun. You have to have the people and facilities around for that and I’m glad you found them. The
heat sucks but then you might just get on that bike and head north too…
Semper fi, if you get this far north…
Jim
Damn! Fucking A Shau was relentless! Another good soldier down. Jurgens on the other hand? We’ll see I guess if he gets a dose of reality, before during or after you take your little stroll. I would bet he does. I get caught up in the terrible losses occurring with each episode and go back and reread them to make sure I understand all the details. Great read as always Jim! Hope you had a peaceful Memorial Day! SemperFi!
Thanks Jack, appreciate the support and yes, we lost a ton in that valley. So did they but they had many more to lose.
Semper fi,
Jim
This episode reminded me of the sniper mortar fire at Kham Duc around this time fifty years ago. One round here or there on Sat. then walking their fire through the Arty. pit and ammo dump the next morning. A lot of memories.
A small correction, after Tex fired his rounds from the recoilless, you went back (to) the 60, etc.
Thanks Jerome, for the editing help.
Working away on the next segment. Maybe I will turn out one that is clean, finally!
Appreciate the association and the support too…
Semper fi,
Jim
Just wanted to say it reads fine. Why does that guy have to keep correcting your spelling? If he was in country he must have been a REMF.
Well, Daniel, the guys correcting the spelling are actually helping me out because you cannot
go to final print with a lot of clerical errors and be taken seriously in the literary world.
So, thanks for your comment but correct me where you can. You are the only editors I have!
Semper fi,
Jim
“I finally set the radios aside and looked at the dying embers of the sun, getting ready to slip down below the eastern ridge that rose up to contain our part of the A Shau on the near side.” I think you mean the “western” rather than “eastern”.
Yes, of course, and thank you Terry. My mind got turned around along with what is left of my intellect!
Thanks for the help.
Semper fi,
Jim
No offense meant LT. One of the many jobs I’ve had was working on a land survey crew. Keeping directions straight becomes second nature very quickly. When you are in the midst of writing it is easy to turn little things around. I like reading Louis L’amour westerns because he researched his locations and what he described was what was actually there. Your writing has that same feel. I can keep where you are at because your descriptions are that accurate. Keep up the good work.
I have maps and my writing of the time. I have this kind of strangely indelible memory to this day.
I am using all of that. I can feel and taste that brown water of the roiled and rolling Bong Song, the twists
and turns down that valley and the exudation from those strange gray rock walls. The beauty of the deadly scenario
is not unlike an old science fiction novel by a man named Godwin. He wrote of a planet named Ragnorak and I think the book was titled The Survivors.
The elements of the dynamically intense valley in analytical detail are as much of the story as the Marines, the fire support personnel and the enemy.
The enemy in the A Shau is like itself, fighting death and life itself…to be last in line…to put everyone and every thing else before it…
Thanks for that compliment and the written recognition of your words written here…
Semper fi,
Jim
Jim, I have been reading every installment since you started writing and posting them. I also read the book and anxiously await every installment and the next book. I was stationed with the 5th SF Group in 1970. I never had to do what you did because I was Signal Intelligence and wasn’t needed in the bush. But I am in awe and very appreciative of what you “grunts” had to through in Vietnam and other wars. I wonder if you have ever considered a movie being made from your writings? I think it would be a very well received and watched movie. I believe it would be on the level of “We Were Soldiers.” Thank you for your service and for writing of your experiences and sharing them with us.
Thanks Harvel. The movie world works like the literary world. You generally make it if you are connected already by family, friends or cronies.
You don’t get a movie made because you have good material. Just turn on your television and you will understand what I’m talking about.
Semper fi, and thanks for the sentiment though…
Jim
Been thinking about connections to the movie side of this discussion and was thinking that Gary Sinise would be a good man to get a copy of your book to, for other reasons as well as a movie.
Gary’s heart has turned to the U.S. Vets and he spends as much time as possible working with and for them. He is very interested in improving the VA assistance for our troops. This book would give him and the VA counselors, great insight in dealing with Vets and PTSD.
Jim you need to send him and autographed book with your address and phone number included.
You can’t send a movie star of his caliber anything. Nothing gets through the system to reach him
if you send to his agency or even his agent. Goes right into the waste basket. I have worked for Hollywood.
There is no entry from the outside. You get in from the inside and I am out here.
Thanks for thinking about Gary and the movie side of things, however.
Most kind of you…as I know you to be…
Semper fi,
Jim
Jurgens needs to be gone. But in my heart I Know he won’t be. What a poor excuse for a Marine. Thanks Lt Semper fi
As I have written to others on here Roger. Jurgens was a card I was dealt. What do you do with
a bad card. Better than no card? Sometimes, yes, specially if he could influent other not so bad cards…
semper fi,
Jim
Discard it.
I don’t know what to discard here, John. What is your intent with the one word comment?
Semper fi,
Jim
I think the comment “discard” refers to eliminating Jergens?
Discard It.
Your story about your time in Hell is so on the level that all who servered or just know someone who did can feel some of the day to day actions and feeling of those who were there. I want my grand children to read this story from the first day to last so they may know just some of hell that we who were there felt. Of course no one will feel the pain of loss of humanity for the time in Hell. Thank you for all you did and are doing
Thanks Robert. About the best credibility for the story is comments by guys who were there talking about it.
They know. They have to know if they were down there in that shit. It’s good to read what you wrote and I thank you.
Semper fi,
Jim
The price exacted by that damn valley has already exceeded Any sense of worth. In life I agree, them that were there get the privilege of naming the shithole anything they want. I know the story is what is compelling your tale, but a very sovereign Lord has chosen you to tell the story. Maybe someday in a War College class your work will be used to teach how the doers get it done when the command staff are out to lunch. Have I said it right? This is how a combat story must be told. Thank you again for taking on this gut wrenching job. Fi. Poppa Joe
My book will never be in a war college class Poppa. That’s not what they teach.
And you know it. They can’t have that stuff in a class because nobody would be believe it
and if they did it would be an indictment of the training they have done.
In order to lead men I had to fear them. I was trained that it was the other way around.
When it came home I had to reflect on my own pain in order to grow stronger.
I had to learn not to commit violence unless violence came
to me and begged me to give it violence in return.
Thanks for the usual great comment.
Semper fi,
Jim
Learning something more about who you are now each time we have one of these short conversations. Thank you for your open candid answers and this one showed me just how polyannish I can be. Our grandson has seen his first combat in the last three days, got word out to his Dad. These conversations will help me not to screw up with him like I did with his Dad. Get some rest LT. Poppa
I am most tickled if I can help Poppa. Talking to guys in the thick of it is hard because they can’t talk
back to you until they get home. My Basic School Class friend Russ tried to talk to me over the arty net
while I was out there. I could not tell him anything. Everyone was listening.
Be very aware of just how sensitive his situation is with friendlies.
Note how many embedded reporters were lost in Iraq. None of them were from friendly fire.
All of them were, except for the reporting, of course….
Semper fi, my friend,
Jim
I missed the first couple of posts ..But I’ll get to them when I buy the book ……Just want to say I’m Navy .87-90 .. Arresting gear ..Cv 60 ……My father inlaw was a door Gunner m60 on hueys ……He was jump qualed …He really only talked to me about his tour in Vietnam ….Only when he was rather drunk ….I can see why…Reading what kind of combat you had to deal with ….Thank you for your service ….Wish I could find out what unit he was with … Particularly since you had army birds flying resupply…..Your tiyr has me in the edge of my seat n me looking around like I’m right beside you
Thanks Roger, and I much appreciate the compliment in your writing on here.
Thank you and many others who’ve written on here I’m certain I would loved to have served
with. I got the luck of the draw, just like my men did. And then the cards were played
one after another…
Semper fi,
Jim
I feel lucky to have been a DUSTOFF medic and didn’t have to pound the ground like you guys did. I’m totally hanging on every portion of this.
What I would have given at times just to get aboard a chopper and fly up to where it was cool.
The heat was such a killer of everything, including my wanting to go on sometimes. Thanks for writing in
and saying something.
Semper fi,
Jim
Tex stood up without answering my question. He talked into the Prick 25 handset and began his report, walking back and forth behind the cover the Ontos provided, Fusner following, connected to the man by the long curly cord.
The near future may well depend upon the report Tex gave, hope he layed it on correctly to his command !!
Thanks for keeping me on the edge of my seat once again James.
SEMPER Fi
Thank you my friend. I have just put up the next segment. Thanks for your very intently studied comment.
Semper fi,
Jim
There are thousands of readers of your episode (like me) who are feeling pain and anguish due to turn of events there in the A Shau. Nothing but deep admiration for you and all who served there and endured more than anyone’s fair share of a marathon dance with death…Through your writing, we are there with you through each up and down and hell throws everything imaginable at you. May God remain with you as you recount these horrific events, LT.
As usual, Mr. Spot on accurate and cogent analyst, you throw one right over the plate.
Endurance in staying alive from one moment to the next, knowing good and bad fortune were playing
such huge roles in your survival were so damned tough,
not to mention all the other worries, pain and discomforts.
Thank you for clarifying…as usual.
Semper fi, my friend,
Jim
I got so damn worked up I started reading faster and faster. Had to take a breath and slow down. Crisp segment sir.
Hey Al, that’s quite a compliment to my writing and I think you for that.
I am at it tonight with that motivation I got from you!
Semper fi,
Jim
Dang, so engrossed in this river crossing! Hurry up and wait!
A few edits
I went back up (to) the Browning and aimed it at the hill. I realized that I liked shooting the gun but I had no real target. The smoke from the 106 rounds was clearing.
“Will this thing make it across?” I asked. “Not like we have an (any) more ammo for it, anyway.”
Nguyen held out a section of the rope he hadn’t work(ed) on (out) (delete) toward me, both arms spread. He waited.
“Oh no,” I said, not even knowing that I’d spoken until Fusner asked me what I (w)as talking about.
Again so appreciative of your sharp eye.
Noted and corrected.
Semper fi,
Jim
I think The only play that’s consistent with survival is the “keep moving” mantra. The A Shau seems to be able to eat up whatever solution you come too and punish you by offering something even more nefarious than the last obstacle as you move through her….. like some evil wicked Demi-God. Jergens has cost more life than he’s worth. Time to trade home out I hope. Maybe just toss him on the resupply bird……. but then what of his platoon……. Jim I’m enjoying this read on many levels. I wish it never happened, but it did. Now people, especially the younger ones can read this and get a solid chronological picture of what is like to truly be in a force on force chess game with your life bet on the outcome. Sorry to hear about Tex. He just wasn’t conditioned properly to the danger I recon…. I was rooting for him.
It was hard to train for the unknown. A lot of Marine training does emphasize adaptation. The beach you hit may have a sand bar
offshore. Whoops. Whom ever thought we’d fight down in some enemy held valley. Try training in artillery for that circumstance when
you are out on the plains of Fort Sill, Oklahoma!
Thanks for the comment and for the support…
Semper fi,
Jim
Enjoy your books very much. Find them very interesting. Keep up the great work…
Thanks Ariene, glad you like them. Working away here to get the second in this series up by August.
Thanks for writing in and helping me along…
Semper fi,
Jim
Another officer pays the price! Perhaps your alias of junior, saved your butt. Tex had to finish his job to make up for the loss of his men, it was a matter of honor, fear be damned. Texans are like that, yeah they are.
Hopefully when you get the company across the river, you will have someone who knows how to operate the Onto.
As you know, I am not going to tell you what happens in the segments ahead.
You are something as a detective and investigator though…
Semper fi, brother,
Jim
Jim, one keeps thinking about the appropriate song when reading about your efforts to get the company across the Bong Son. How about “bridge over troubled waters?”
How appropriate, you are correct. A great song and an eerie strange time. I could not get away from that river. It just kept dragging
me back. The Bong Song. Not even the right name! Like most everything else in my life…some form of fakery, phoniness or downright deception.
Thanks for the comment, as usual my friend…
Semper fi,
Jim
There is one thing in your life that is not phony and you know what I am talking about. When your time draws nigh, you will then recognize it and accept it as the only real truth in life. I pray you will not wait until the last moment to reach that conclusion my friend.
Semper fi
Thank you J, not for the application of your faith in my ‘getting it,’ but in the fact that you care enough about me to write what you are writing here.
That is remarkable and so very admirable. You are a terrific man and I cannot thank you enough.
Semper fi, my friend,
Jim
Jim we are brothers in the same world and generation and that should mean something. We are here to look after one another in war and in peace. We also have another brother who died for us, so that we could live beyond our journey on this earth. We need only to acknowledge Him and believe.
How can anyone describe that single, solitary moment in time when you suddenly realize that someone is gone….it takes a moment, sometimes a battle rages inside your own brain that ‘no, it can’t be, I just don’t see him…he was right there a second ago…he was fine…he was with me..he was RiGHT there!!”….how does anyone describe the range of emotions that pummel you, rips the breath from your lungs and makes your heart stand still.
How?…….and yet sometimes, that recognition, acknowledgement, and painful acceptance takes only a few seconds…because the rounds are still coming….and you know that if you survive a few more seconds..or days…then you might get the chance to tell Tex good bye….and thanks… and for the rest if your life you will know and honor the memory of a guy that you had never seen before, that came out of no where…and stood beside you..and most likely saved your life…. and folks some times wonder why old men cry when they touch a cold black wall of marble…..and slowly trace a name etched in it…………Semper Fi
Larry Goldsmith. Should be Larry Wordsmith!
I much enjoy reading your comments because they are so well written
no matter what subject you choose to comment on.
Thanks for giving us all that.
The depth of your thought is really what I am commenting on.
I like the way your mind works and thank you for putting that mind down in words on here.
Semper fi,
Jim
I find myself searching my FB page at least a couple times a day to see if you have posted another chapter. First thing I do in the morning, last thing at night. We have all heard of the A Shau Valley, but no one has laid out the horrors that our troops faced as well as you. Your writing is excellent, your descriptions so graphic that one feels like they are almost right there with you; but thankful to be in the safety of our homes at our computers instead – not praying that one of those rounds doesn’t find us. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you for reading the story, as it goes on Marshall. And thanks for the compliments in your words.
It’s a rendition of what really happened, although I still wonder at some details as I write them down.
Who could ever forget the A Shau. A lot of man died there in that war and it was poorly understood what was
happening or allowed to happen.
Thanks for the comment.
Semper fi,
Jim
I do the same his life and time in that valley are an addiction anf thank god i am to young to have been there but if i were there i would have been right next to this man trying to learn everything that he could teach me about artillery fire and map reading.The Lt is the one that I would follow to the end
Damn Jim,
I am amazed that charlie didn’t Kill most of you! You certainly have a Guardian Angel following you about.
I forget who said it but it went something like this, “Uncommon Valor Was Common Place”, I’d say that pretty much describes You and some of your men. What a shitty war experience, Tex gone in a blink of the eye must have really shook you hard. I’m amazed that you even sleep at all these days. I personally want to thank you for your service and duty to our country!
Keep it coming please as I eagerly look forward to the second TEN DAYS!!!
Yes, guardian angels had something to do with it, although I don’t think Clarence from It’s a Wonderful Life
would have been a decent fit for most of us! Thanks for the cogent and meaningful comment and the compliment
in the writing. Semper fi,
Jim
not to correct you but I think it was Admiral Nimitz describing the Marines on Iwo Jima when he said “Uncommon valor was a common virtue”.I just found this and will be reading all of it.Thank you and do not change the writing style it is elemental andgenuine not the writings of someone who had not lived this.
I don’t think I can change the writing style James because I don’t know what the style is!
I just write it down as it comes to me, along with referencing the maps and letters and diary I kept.
Thanks for liking the work and coming on here to say so.
Semper fi,
Jim
Bong Son ….
We called it the Bong Song, even though I knew all the way back then that the name
was not correct. It was what was…and remains for those of us who went there…
Semper fi,
Jim
I’m gonna need surgery if you sucker punch me again, Jim. What a segment! I almost drowned once in a pool full of people, alone in a crowd? I can maybe get the least sense of your position here although drowning would be more peaceful than what you faced. Have I said “thank you” recently? For then and now. Gotta go practice my salute for the Fourth of July.
Sometimes, you make me laugh while reading your comments Walt. Surgery? Thanks for thanking me. I will smile at your encouragement as I finish the nest segment this morning at the coffee shop.
Thanks for helping me to keep going.
Semper fi,
Jim
If you got an instant of comic relief from this journey you’re taking me on I have succeeded.
In retrospect it was a comic horror film in real life, but could not be seen that way from the inside.
Now, over here, some of it is indeed darkly humorous…and you too Walt!
Semper fi,
Jim
I wish you wrote in 10 page segments! Very captivating once again. It will be a long few days waiting for your next post. Thank you, and all those with whom you served.
Writing as fast as I can and trying to get it up while I work to meet the requirements laid upon me by a regular
publisher. Thanks for wanting more and wanting it faster.
Semper fi,
Jim
Well Jim…just another awesome segment…and with all the things going on simultaneously…your leadership is the reason your guys have a chance to get across the river…the day to day, hell, minute to minute survival in that valley…I don’t see how anyone did it…as soon as you catch a break something else jumps up to bite you in the ass…I thought a lot about Nam this weekend and all that were lost…it’s still all seems so useless…most of the war was about fighting for each other and survival…no real objective other than that…take ground, give it back…like a giant dog chasing its tail…great writing again, as usual. I know I say that every time, but it’s true every time…to use some of my NC vernacular, you done good back then and you’re doing good now…
Golly Gee Mark! Thanks for that wonderful comment. I was trying to do good back then but
was sure having one hell of a time separating anything out that I could call good.
Easier now, but this story has kind of a life of its own. Just like answering comments
that I cannot not answer (this one is number 7536) because who could upon reading?
Thank you for the most excellent comment. I much appreciate…
Semper fi,
Jim
Heard “it don’t mean nothing” but it does. It really does.
Yes, it surely does Tony. That expression meant just the opposite of what it said, but you had to be there and using it
to get the bitter irony of it.
Semper fi,
Jim
Another gut clenching segment. More gut clenching than the prospect of an audit by the IRS. Keep’em coming…..
Thanks Ed, you are a important to my effort here, like some others who take the time to tell me what they really think
in the clear and revealing their identities. Little tougher on Amazon comments because anonymous people are not so kind
and there’s no reply I can make.
Thanks for the comment and your support.
Semper fi,
Jim
Another great segment. Sorry about Tex. thanks for all you did and for all you are doing now. How are book sales going ( if I may ask).
Rick
Book sales remain strong for a very small book seller like me.
I’ve sold about two thousand so far, maybe three, since they only give you totals once a month.
Not bad, really. Unless I have a big publisher in New York there is no
real likelihood that I can have a big audience, but that’s okay.
I stay at it. My audience is primarily veterans and those
who want to understand us.
Thanks for asking and for writing on here.
Semper fi,
Jim
Darn !! you are not only a good CO you are a good writer too.
Thanks a million Harold. Means a lot to hear from guys like you saying stuff like that.
Semper fi,
Jim
Damn just when you think things might change and get a break. Jergens is still in the sacrifice everyone to cover his sorry ass mode. Hope you are walking him downriver to get Tex’s body. Hope he nailed that 50.
When I’d first looked at the bridge scene I’d known that getting the company across was going to take longer than I’d hoped, simply (become) the water crossing would take time and then running the Marines over the bridge in fire team size only would add to that. (because)
Thank you again for your support, Pete.
Noted and corrected
Semper fi
Jim
I feel that if was a 5.56 round that killed Tex, Jergens could possably die of acute lead poisoning by way of .45acp.
Thanks for the prediction and conclusion Larry. Wait for the next segment and you will know.
Appreciate the detail of your reading and your intelligent conjecture…
Semper fi,
Jim
Damn It!
Damn, the bridging unit is short, Damn, the Ontos is out of ammo, Damn, Tex and all the other army troops are dead, Damn, the Gunney and the rest of the company are still across the river and will be until that sniper is taken out, Damn, night fall is coming and still no resupply, Damn it, Damn it all!
Yes, one thing after another. Although it was the shit happening all at the same time
that was the worst. Thanks for writing that comment. It made me smile.
Semper fi,
Jim
Thanks Thomas for that compliment! One word. Laconic. Said it all.
Semper fi,
Jim
You’ll need darkness and smoke(if you can get it) to cover the crossing. Jurgens needs a round in the ass, unless he’s got a really good excuse.
Reading every segment more than once. I know what you’ve said about the movie potential but the producers need to read this. Not your every day war story.
I don’t hold up much hope for the movies. They like that Mel Gibson stuff, although Platoon had some bits of good stuff in it,
as did Full Metal Jacket. I don’t think Hollywood will ever see it simply because that is not how Hollywood works. Family, friends,
cronies and relatives. There you have almost everyone who works there, or at least gets well paid for working there. I am none of those things.
Thanks for your support and writing it on here.
Semper fi,
Jim
Funny you should mention those two movies. I wondered if you had seen them and what your thoughts were. A vet I worked with who drove construction equipment said they were all BS. Like yourself, I thought there were “bits” in some that had merit. Never having been in country, much less in the shit, all I have to judge is my knowledge of how things, life and people work.
Keep the episodes coming Jim. Good story, and despite a good knowledge of war machines, I learned about an Ontos.
Tim
The opening sequence to Saving Private Ryan was about as real as you can get.
You got to watch the protagonist punch through the line up the hill. The only factor
not valid was how many he would have lost in his company. Like all of them!
Platoon had some good advisors too in covering some aspects of the racial stuff and
friendly fire. They covered friendly as personal though and it’s really not that way.
Make me safe, and you live. Make me die and you die first.
Semper fi,
Jim